top of page
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

PENNSYLVANIA ROYALTY AUDITS • PROTOTYPE

Your royalty check is a math problem. Nobody is checking the math.

Operators compute your royalty, deduct what they want, and mail you a number you can't verify. We rebuild the check from the state's own production records — well by well, decimal by decimal — and show you exactly where it leaks.

3 operators

$19,682

25.2%

1 gap

tracked across one owner's 2026 statements

paying on the same leasehold, three different ways

taken in deductions by the largest payer

an operator that stopped paying in May, unexplained

Three ways a royalty check quietly shrinks

None of these show up on the stub as an error. They show up as small print — or as nothing at all.

Wells you're owed on but never see

Interests get sold, wells get transferred, division orders go stale — and payments stop with no letter, no notice, nothing. If you aren't matching every operator against every month, a stopped check looks like a slow well.

New wells get permitted and completed inside units that may include your land. Production alone doesn't prove you're in the unit — and if the division order was never set up right, the first checks go out without you on them.

Post-production costs — gathering, compression, transportation — get taken out of your royalty whether or not your lease permits it. On a lease that promises one-eighth of revenue 'less taxes and adjustments', a 25% deduction load is a question, not a given.

The operator who just stops paying

Deductions your lease never allowed

How an audit works

You send paper. We send back proof — a report you can hand to the operator, or to an attorney.

1

You send your records

Recent check stubs or statements, your lease, and your division order. Photos or scans are fine. We work from what you already have in a drawer.

2

We rebuild every check

We pull the wells' production from Pennsylvania DEP records, match them to your statements by API number, and recompute what should have been paid: production × price × your decimal, minus only what your lease allows.

3

You get the report

Paid vs. should-have-paid, deduction rates vs. your lease language, missing wells, and payment gaps — each finding with its next step: a division-order request, a demand letter, or an attorney referral.

What every audit checks

✓ Deduction rate vs. lease

Every deduction category on the stub, tested against the exact words of your lease.

✓ Payment gaps

Every operator, every month. A missing payment is flagged the month it happens, not years later.

✓ Missing wells

New permits and completions near your tract checked against the wells on your statements.

✓ Decimal interest

Your division-order decimal recomputed from your acreage and the unit size.

✓ Transfers & stale division  orders

When an interest moves between operators, we verify your pay record moved with it. 

✓ Price received

The per-Mcf price on your stub compared with what the operator reported and regional index prices.

Try it: the 30-second deduction check

Take any recent stub. Enter the gross value of your royalty and what you were actually paid. If the gap surprises you, that's the audit.

Deduction checker

One well, one month, one stub. No account, nothing saved.

Pre-filled with the August figures from the sample report below. The gap counts everything withheld — deductions, taxes, and fees; the full audit separates them line by line.

Simple pricing

pricing

Flat fees. We never take a percentage of money recovered — that keeps the audit honest and keeps us out of the legal side of your case.

Single Audit

$149

One full audit of your royalty income, like the sample above.

Up to 5 operators, one year of statements

Deductions tested against your lease language

Decimal interest recomputed from your acreage

Payment-gap and missing-well check

Written report with next steps for every finding.

Monitoring

$39 / month

Every new statement checked as it arrives, against your audited baseline.

Each month's statements verified on arrival

Instant flag on a missed or short payment

Deduction-rate drift alerts

New-well and unit-change watch near your tract

Annual summary report for your records or attorney.

Pennsylvania only, for now — every state keeps its production records differently, and we'd rather do one state right. Audits are currently prepared by hand, report within two weeks.

how
checker
report

This is an actual report, built from one Bradford County owner's own statements, lease, and the state production records. Names and owner numbers are withheld; every dollar figure is real.

request

Natural gas royalties • Ulster Township, Bradford County, Pennsylvania • Prepared by Royalty Watchdog

Owner

Withheld (sample)

Period audited

Jan – Oct 2026

Statements reviewed

24

Report date

November 18, 2026

Lease

June 25, 2003 • 249.5 acres

Owner's tract

86.82 acres (34.80%)

Royalty rate

1/8 (12.5%)

Wells on statements

5

PAYMENTS STOPPED

1 operator

Last payment May 21, 2026. No notice, no explanation on file.

HIGHEST DEDUCTION RATE

25.2%

Taken by the largest payer on a lease that never says 'free of cost.'

Status

Paying monthly

Paying monthly

Stopped after May

24

Operator

Operator A

Operator B

Operator C

Total

Amount

$14,479.83

$4,419.32

$783.27

$19,682.42

Gross value

$1,125.37

$339.37

—

Deduction rate

25.2%

17.7%

—

Net paid

$815.78

$270.70

No payment

Royalty Audit Report

SAMPLE REPORT

TOTAL PAID, JAN–OCT 2026

$19,682.42

Across 24 statements from three operators on the same leasehold.

Payments by operator — 2026 year to date

Operators anonymized in this sample. In a client report each is named, with owner numbers and per-well detail.

One month under the microscope — August 2026 production

Operator

Operator A

Operator B

Operator C

Same lease, same township, same production month — two operators deducting at rates nearly eight points apart. Net paid is after all withholdings, including taxes, so the full gap between gross and net runs slightly higher than the deduction rate alone.

Findings

HIGH

Operator C stopped paying in May — interest appears transferred

Last payment: May 21, 2026 • $58.95 | Paid by Operator C in 2026: $783.27 | Payments since: None

Operator C paid monthly through May, then nothing. Over the same period, Operator A's share of the leasehold rose — and the owner's decimal interest with Operator A increased between the March and August statements on the three wells Operator C previously held. The evidence points to the interest moving to Operator A effective April 2026, but no division order confirming the transfer has been produced.

Next step: Division-order requests are open with all three operators (filed November 18, 2026). Do not assume the transfer is complete until Operator A's division order lists all three wells at the corrected decimal.

HIGH

Deductions of 25.2% on a lease that does not say 'free of cost'

Operator A deductions: 25.2% of gross | Operator B deductions: 17.7% of gross | Lease allowance: Taxes & adjustments only

The 2003 lease pays one-eighth of revenue realized, less taxes, assessments, and adjustments. It does not contain 'free of cost' language, and it does not name gathering, compression, or transportation as deductible. Whether deductions at 25.2% — or 17.7% — are permitted under this lease is a legal question, and it is the single largest number in this report: at Operator A's rate, roughly a quarter of every gross dollar never reaches the owner.

Next step: Referred for a Pennsylvania oil & gas attorney's review of the lease language. The audit establishes the amounts; the attorney establishes what the lease allows.

MEDIUM

Three new wells completed in October — no royalties yet, division orders unconfirmed

A three-well pad (3HC / 4HC / 5HC) was permitted in July 2026 and completed in October 2026 near the leasehold. The laterals do not run through the owner's tract on the records available, so no royalty may be owed — but this is exactly the moment to get division orders right, before first checks are cut on a wrong unit map.

Next step: Working-interest and unit-inclusion confirmations requested from both operators, November 18, 2026.

MEDIUM

Two producing units — inclusion of the owner's land unverified

Two nearby units (1H wells, originally drilled 2012) are in production. Production alone does not prove the owner's acreage is inside either unit, and no pooling declaration has been produced for either. If any part of the 249.5-acre leasehold sits inside those units, the owner is owed on them.

Next step: Declarations of pooling to be pulled from the Bradford County Register & Recorder, Towanda, PA, and checked against the leasehold boundary.

CHECKED • CLEAR

No missing months from Operators A and B

All 24 statements received in 2026 reconcile month-to-month for Operators A and B, January through October, with no gaps. The five wells on the owner's statements — Sidonio 2H, 4HC and 5HC, Hartz 1H, and Paul Bra 5H — appear consistently across the period.

Where this case stands

1. Eleven inquiries are open with the three operators — division orders, payment status, and working-interest percentages — all acknowledged with case numbers as of November 18, 2026.

2. The deduction question (Finding 2) goes to a PA oil & gas attorney with this report attached.

3. Monitoring continues monthly: the next statement from each operator gets checked against this baseline as it lands.

Method: statements reconciled against Pennsylvania DEP production records and the recorded lease. This report audits arithmetic, decimals, deductions, and payment continuity. It is not legal advice and does not interpret the lease — questions of what a lease permits are referred to a licensed Pennsylvania oil & gas attorney.

Comma-separated

Service

To run the audit we'll ask for scans of your recent statements, lease, and division order. Never send originals. Never include a Social Security number — owner number and statements are enough.

Request an audit

Tell us what you're working with and attach what you have. Scans or clear photos are fine — never send originals, and never send a Social Security number. We reply by email to confirm the audit before any work starts.

Questions owners ask

Is this legal advice?

No — and that's deliberate. We audit the math: production, price, decimals, deductions, and payment continuity, all checked against public records and the documents you provide. When a finding turns on what your lease legally permits, we hand you the numbers and refer you to a Pennsylvania oil & gas attorney for the interpretation.

​

What do you need from me?

Your recent check stubs or statements (a year is ideal), your lease, and your division order if you have one. Scans or clear photos are fine. If a document is missing, the audit will say so — finding what's missing is part of the job.

​

How do you verify what I should have been paid?

Pennsylvania operators report production to the DEP by well. We match those records to your statements by API well number, then recompute your royalty from production, price, and your decimal interest — and compare, line by line, with what you were paid.

​

Do you guarantee I'll recover money?

No. An audit finds discrepancies and documents them; recovering money is a separate step that may involve the operator or an attorney. Anyone who guarantees recovery before seeing your statements is selling you something.

​

Which states do you cover?

Pennsylvania only right now. Production databases and royalty rules differ by state, and the audit is only worth paying for if it's built on the right records. Texas and Oklahoma are the planned next states.

Sample report figures are from a real Bradford County, PA case, anonymized with the owner's knowledge. Deduction rates shown are as recorded on the operator statements.

Royalty Watchdog • royaltywatchdog.com — prototype landing page and sample report, November 2026. Royalty Watchdog is a royalty-check auditing service, not a law firm. Reports verify arithmetic and payment records; they are not legal advice.

bottom of page